DIVERSITY OF IDEAS

By: Zoë Muntaner

Santa Monica City Council meetings can be a hoot or a total bummer, depending of your idea of fun.  City Hall steps where the Santa Monica Area Interfaith Council hosted a local Community Vigil for the Orlando victims was a setting for a hopeful outcome, after all we ended the vigil singing PEACE, SALAM, SHALOM.  You would think that transferred to City Chambers, correct?  It depends on your idea of peace.

Nightclub Shooting Las Vegas Vigil
A person places a rose by a flag during a vigil at The Center, a community center for the LGBT community, Sunday, June 12, 2016, in Las Vegas. The vigil was for the victims of the Pulse nightclub shooting in Orlando. (AP Photo/John Locher)

I’m so glad I have this outlet, the best thing that has happened to me in a long time. If I don’t get my two minutes extended to finish an important presentation, I sit in a comfy chair or bed and write.  My voice is read globally from a phone, laptop or mobile device.  Thank you Jesus, Mary, Moses and all the prophets before me.  Speaking about prophets who were often persecuted — not an easy existence — when our City Manager Rick Cole told me he thought I was one of the prophetic voices in Santa Monica, I didn’t know how to react.  Is that a compliment or a premonition?  Last week I was TAKEN,  spent 5 days in captivity.  I was abused and my civil rights were violated left and right.  I was not charged with any crime.  My crime is advocating for the homeless, I’ve been voicing my opposition to the harassment and criminalization of this vulnerable population.  Remember a statement from a previous post?  My commitment to use my voice for the voiceless?  I walk my talk.  Is it a crime to be poor?  Is it a crime to be mentally ill?   The lack of compassion from members of the Santa Monica Police Department is a scandal in the making, actually is a scandal period, is made already.   The lack of ACTION from our city staff is an embarrassment.  Mr. Cole, is time to use that moral imperative you spoke two city council meetings ago.  Where is the moral compass of Santa Monica?  Wait for the story, it has so many layers, twists, and turns that I’m going back to my New York storytelling roots, tell it on stage to broadcast via livestream.  Believe the hype, it is gripping stuff.

”We are here today because we have a power we have yet to exercise” ~Eric Garcetti, Los Angeles Mayor on TACO Challenge Speech

I’m here to exercise the power of my voice.  I won’t be silenced!  Read previous posts, I LOVE MY FIRST AMENDMENT.  You mess with it, you are messing with a whole powerful global industry.  Do you think I’m fighting this battle alone? Seriously?  Bring it!  I’m fearless.  When it comes to standing for my rights and injustice of the powerless & voiceless, who are harassed day in and day out in our city and around the globe, something kicks in.  Think global, act local, I’m a localist!  For now, I’ll be focusing on local issues, because someone has to do the job,  it feels like a calling to me.

Back to City Council tonight, after reading Bill Bauer Monday Commentary on the Santa Monica Daily Press, I had hopes.  You would think council members read his column, apparently not.  Since he is way better writer than I am, here is a bit:

“The frustration level mounts, people become more unhappy  and dissatisfied with the way they are being served -or ignored.  Special interests are taking charge and we know what they want – benefit for their causes and conditions over the needs and the desires of the public.” ~Bill Bauer, Columnist Santa Monica Daily Press

Tony Vasquez provided enough fuel for me to write all night.  But I have a previous engagement to attend.  The order of business is IDEAS LA.  I’m writing this post, directly and live from the Broad Stage, in the glamorous city of Santa Monica.

IDEASLosAngeles_TelAvivUniversityAmericanFriends

IDEAS Los Angeles is a project by Tel Aviv University-American Friends in partnership with dozens of corporations, private businesses, community organizations, institutes of higher learning and media outlets to create a space where global business leaders, futurists, studio heads, movie and television producers, healthcare providers, doctors, thought leaders, entrepreneurs, Tel Aviv University administrators, professors, and alumni can come together and share ideas.  IDEAS LA (Israel, Digital, Entrepreneurs, Arts, and Science) is hosted by American Friends of Tel Aviv University, a national nonprofit organization dedicated to supporting Israel’s largest institution of higher learning.

IDEAS wants to inspire people to think deeper and more broadly by engaging with inventors and innovators tackling some of the most exciting challenges in the world today.  American Friends of Tel Aviv University supports Israel’s most influential, comprehensive, and sought-after center of higher learning, Tel Aviv University (TAU). TAU ranked #75 globally and #1 in Israel in a 2015 Reuters survey of the 100 most innovative universities. It is one of a handful of elite universities rated as the best producers of successful startups, and TAU alumni rank #9 in the world for the amount of venture capital they attract.

It’s not an official IDEAS event without the brightest, most creative minds speaking!  That’s why I’m here, to pick their brains.  So far is a hoot!  This is the place to be today and tomorrow. The code LATINX will get each registrant 50% off all ticket prices.  Courtesy of yours truly, DIVERSITY MATTERS.

IDEAS on the future of digital technology in, Health, Lifestyle, Entertainment, and Media.  I GOT INVESTORS SUPER INTERESTED IN FUNDING DIVERSITY MATTERS! Woohoo!!!!  If you are an entrepreneur at any stage, from seed to funded, you must be here, is all I have to say.  Run don’t walk.  It is the event of the season!  Just before Summer Solstice, great timing, two days before Shabbat, perfection!SelfieMirror_20160616_111658

Inspiring leaders and visionaries like, Jonathan Littman President of Bruckheimer Television; Ayelet Zurer – Actress and Producer; Jonathan Gluck – Senior Executive and Corporate Counsel at Heritage Provider Network; Robert Watson – President of Nanthealth; Alon Shtruzman – President of Keshet International; Marc Graboff – President of Global Business & Legal Affairs for Production Management & Studios at Discovery Communications are just a few of the 70+ industry leaders that will be sharing their vision for the future of digital technology, at IDEAS Los Angeles.

Here is the LINE UP:

Adam Becker, Founder & CEO, Egg Stage
Adam Mendler, CEO, The Veloz Group
Alexis Madrigal, Editor in Chief, Fusion TV
Alicia Menendez, Anchor & Special Correspondent, Fusion TV
Alon Shtruzman, CEO, Keshet International
Andrew Wallenstein, Co-Editor-in-Chief, Variety
Audrey Melnik, Founder, Funnel Ventures
Billy Shaw Susanto, Co-Founder & CEO, Pundit
Brendan Farrell, Founder, How Loud Inc.
Dr. Bonnie Feldman, Principal, Dr Bonnie 360
Dr. Brennan Spiegel,  Director of Health Services Research, Cedars-Sinai Health System
Brian MacMahon, Head Honcho, Expert Dojo
Caitlin Thompson, Director of Content, Acast
Caspar Van Winterfeldt, Co-Founder & Managing Director, Baron VR
Chris Aston, Co-Founder & COO, Pundit
Dave Whelan, Managing Director, Bespoke Business Strategy Inc.
Rabbi David Wolpe, Chief Rabbi, Sinai Temple
Edmond Banayan, Founder & Editor, iHealthcare Perspectives
Fern Langham, Co-Founder, Amplify Effect
Gene Gurkoff, Founder & CEO, Charity Miles
George Eleftheriou, Co-Founder & CEO, Feel
Gilad Neumann, CEO, DogTV
Haris Tsirmpas, Co-Founder & CTO, Feel
Harry Nelson, Founder & Managing Partner, Nelson Hardiman
Heather Rees, Founder, Amplify Effect
Hillary Frey, Executive Editor, Fusion TV
Indu Subaiya, Co-Founder, Health 2.0
James Poole, Co-Founder & CTO, PopChest
Jessica Naziri, Tech Contributor, USA Today
John Bates, Principal, Executive Speaking Success
Jordan Mendler, CTO, The Veloz Group
Dr. Julian Henley, Co-Founder, HealOra
Prof. Joseph Klafter, President, Tel Aviv University
Karen Allen, Karen Allen Consulting
Katherine Lehr, VP of Operations, POLITICO
Klaus Badelt, Co-Founder, Kinonation
Lia Kislev, CEO, Wishi
Liz Plank, Senior Producer & Correspondent, Vox.com
Marc Graboff, President of Global Business & Legal Affairs for Production, Discovery Communications, Inc.
Mayaan Cohen, CEO, Hello Heart
Mette Dyrberg, Founder, MyMee
Mike Stone, CEO & Founder, MakersKit
Miriam Illions, Co-Founder & CMO, Hometalk
Moe Mernick, Head of Business Development, Hometalk
Neal Kaufman, Chief Medical Officer, Canary Health
Nick Desai, Founder & CEO, Heal
Oren Gavriely, CEO, BeatMed
Oron Afek, CEO, BookMD
Rob Rader, General Counsel, Ovation TV
Robert Watson, President, NantHealth
Roey Tsemah, Founder, Whitestone music
Ron Levi, Chief Content Officer, DogTV
Ryan Foland, Director, Blackstone LaunchPad at UCI
Seth Shapiro, CEO, New Amsterdam Media
Steve Baltin, Host, Riffing With on Hulu
Steve Bradbury, Principal, Vlocity Digital
Valerian Bennet, Founder & CEO, PopChest
Dr. Uri Nevo, Dept. of BioMedical Engineering, Tel Aviv University
Prof. Yair Bar Haim, School of Psychological Sciences, Tel Aviv University
Prof. Yael Hanien, Head of Nano Lab, Tel Aviv University

The initial lineup of featured start-ups includes:

Amplify Effect
Beatmed
CharityMiles
DinTV
EggStage
Heal
Healora
Hometalk
How Loud
Kinonation
MakersKit
PopChest
Pundit
Sentio Solutions
Whitestone Music

For more information or to purchase tickets to the IDEAS LA conference, please visit: http://www.ideaslosangeles.com, use code LATINX for a 50% off all ticket prices.

Pundit

See you at the Broad, I partnered with PUNDIT a great new app that allows you to have your own talk show, sorta! I will be talking more about through our livestreams interviews.  Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to listen to the talks from their booth!

To get Pundit go here: GET PUNDIT !!!!!!!!!!!!

 

 

 

DIVERSITY SLAPP

By: Zoë Muntaner

Santa Monica Pony Protester Marcy Winograd Wins – Court of Appeal Dismisses Pony Ride Operators’ Lawsuit as a SLAPP.

In a victory for legislative advocates, the California Court of Appeal (Division 5), a panel of three Justices, unanimously reversed a lower court ruling, and dismissed former Santa Monica pony ride operators’ Tawni Angel and Jason Nestor’s lawsuit against Marcy Winograd as a SLAPP – Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation – designed to chill public debate.

In issuing the ruling, the Court said Winograd’s accusations of animal abuse were protected by California’s legislative privilege.

“I’m grateful that the Court of Appeal sided with those exercising the right of petition to change the law and did not allow this chilling lawsuit to go forward. This is a significant ruling for animal lovers and for anyone petitioning their local or state government for legislative change. The Superior Court’s failure to dismiss the lawsuit against me was dangerous, chilling, and disheartening, but fortunately this appellate decision rights that wrong and affirms the importance of robust public debate and citizen activism.” ~Marcy Winograd

The court ruled that the statements in her articles and television interview relate to the supposed poor treatment the pony ride and petting zoo animals received, and either directly or inferentially solicited public support for her petition to cause the City of Santa Monica to take action to end the pony ride and petting zoo.

BACKGROUND

In March 2014, Winograd launched a petition to close the pony ride and petting zoo featured at the city-sponsored farmers market blocks from her home in Ocean Park. She first learned the pony operators were suing her when a reporter contacted her to get reaction to the operators’ lawyers’ press release announcing the lawsuit.

On September 9, 2014, after hearing arguments from proponents and opponents of the pony ride and petting zoo, the Santa Monica City Council voted to seek alternatives to the pony ride and zoo when the operators’ contract expired, and in May of 2015 the City of Santa Monica closed the animal exhibit after twelve years of ponies circling round and round on hard ground – all the while tied to a metal bar.

At the time, the lawsuit was filed some 1400 people had signed her petition – including school board members (now State Senator Ben Allen), former planning commissioners, two former mayors of Santa Monica, a minister at the Church of Ocean Park, and several merchants on Main Street.

While the Superior Court dismissed the entire SLAPP suit against her co-defendant Danielle Charney, the judge left much of the lawsuit against her intact. On appeal, however, she prevailed on the ground of legislative privilege – in other words, the Court agreed that all of her advocacy efforts were connected to the City Council’s legislative decision and were therefore absolutely privileged from civil suit.

Just breathe

“This is a huge victory for those who value robust public debate, the First Amendment, and legislative advocacy,” said Winograd. “This is good news, indeed.” ~Marcy Winograd

“This is an important decision for animal advocates, and for anyone campaigning to make change through our legislative bodies. The superior court’s ruling failing to toss the lawsuit out in the first instance was dangerous, chilling and disheartening. This appellate decision rights the legal ship and properly restores a very heavy burden to be borne by any plaintiff attacking public advocates.” ~Ira L. Gottlieb, Labor Attorney

I LOVE MY FIRST AMENDMENT

The First Amendment (Amendment I) to the United States Constitution prohibits the making of any law respecting an establishment of religion, impeding the free exercise of religion, abridging the freedom of speech, infringing on the freedom of the press, interfering with the right to peaceably assemble or prohibiting … you get the drill.

Like Marcy, I am an activist, writer and political citizen who loves robust debate.  I love my freedom of speech so much that I self-funded this platform to express my ideas, because two minutes at a City Council meetings was not cutting it for me, and emails were not working for me to accomplish the goals I set to work at.

“Free speech not only lives, it rocks,” Oprah Winfrey, 1998

Remember the  multimillion-dollar defamation lawsuit by Texas cattlemen against the famous talk show host? The Amarillo, Texas, jury, decided the television talk show host did not maliciously harm the U.S. beef industry in a 1996 program on mad cow disease.

 

Oprah
Oprah Winfrey Harvard University commencement address, 2013

 

“I will continue to use my voice. I believed from the beginning that (the lawsuit) was an attempt to muzzle my voice, and I come from a people who have struggled and died in order to have a voice in this country. And I refused to be muzzled.” ~Oprah Winfrey

I’m a media and communications professional, not as wealthy as Oprah, but in the same field.  Lawsuits are part of the game, people get offended and then use the compassion rhetoric to manipulate my speech.  I refuse to censor myself, therefore, I pass each post through a legal advisor to protect the platform.   I’m in the perspective business.  This is my point of view and you are welcome to make comments below.

Purpose

TOUGH LOVE, TOUGH LUCK & MY OWN VOICE

My friend Holly Mosher, whom I’ve written about in this blog, is concerned about my last post because she felt it was a leap to call what Ms. Christopolos said Nazi rhetoric. She wanted me to come from the place of compassion and manners that I laid out in the post.  I value her opinion and that of a small group of men and women who are mentors, advisors and friends.  They supported the post.  They didn’t find anything wrong with it.  Remember,  a month ago I wrote about the time it has taken for me to get the discipline to write again.  After all that trouble, I do a disservice to my readers if I’m not honest with my POV.  I must show up as authentically on the page, as I show in life.  Yes, I’m the Founder of Compassionate Santa Monica, that does not mean that I will compromise my journalistic identity, integrity and style.  I must be transparent in my perspective.  Sometimes, it’s time for tough love, is still love, just a different kind.  Was I compassionate?  You bet I was.  I was compassionate to the millions of Jews who died in the Holocaust, the survivors, and descendants that live in and out of Santa Monica.  Ms.Cristopolos comment was inappropriate and offensive to me and others.  Upon research, I found a quote under the inspiration tab of her social media Pinterest that proves my point:

Exist Elena

What you want me to say?   It makes perfect sense. It’s self-explanatory. Those are her terms, she values the statement enough to post it in social media.  Is this a slap to our faces?  You be the judge of that. She owns it, and she shows it.  That is all.

I will always choose love

On the other hand, I exist on a different term,  I’m not perfect, I own my flaws and humbly apologize when needed.  I stand by what I write because it always comes, and will continue to come, from love.  Follow me here: LOVE

“It is easy in the world to live after the world’s opinion; it is easy in solitude to live after our own; but the great man is he who in the midst of the crowd keeps with perfect sweetness the independence of solitude.“
– Ralph Waldo Emerson

Dare

DIVERSITY MANNERS

By: Zoë Muntaner

I have been told to never let my mood dictate my manners. Is a practice that takes decades to cultivate, and even more to sustain.  In the world of politics, where jabs are constantly thrown at you, the challenge is to keep calm under pressure.  Politics are not for the thin skinned, fragile or coward.

If you are a political citizen, at some point you will become passionate about ideals and campaigns, it is wise to be vigilant about emotions that potentially trigger crisis or disaster, which will later require the skill of a professional to manage.

Am I willing to suffer for this? “ is the question I always ask myself before commiting to action.

“You have to pick the places you don’t walk away from” ~Joan Didion

Experience has taught me to be mindful on the passions I choose. Passion: (n.) from Late Latin passionem “suffering, enduring” stem of Latin pati “to suffer, endure, to hurt.”

I’m Latinx therefore my DNA is already infused with passion. Warning: Proceed with caution.

Manners are the basic building blocks of civil society” ~Alexander McCall Smith

DNA, NOW & CULTURAL APPROPIATION

Cultural Appropiation is the adoption or use of elements of one culture by members of a different culture.  This week’s Santa Monica Downtown Neighbors Association and North of Wilshire Neighbors Association event was themed “Block Party”.  DNA is chaired by Elena Christopoulos a white young female and NOW is chaired by Troy Harris a black  young man.

I grew up going to block parties in Puerto Rico and New York.  So last night I dressed in washed out jeans, plaid shirt, sweater on my waist, LA Dodger cap and sandals. Most guests were overdressed. Travis Pagel and Peter James, the planners who are on the DCP road show were on point with their dress code.  They are busy, and have the toughest  job in town: sell a project that will alter the feel and character of downtown Santa Monica.  I admire their tenacity and have compassion for the trouble they go through doing their job.

I was greeted by a new Santa Monica resident whom I met at the Santa Monica Democratic Club meeting where David Martin presented the DCP. I was surprised when he told me he became a board member of DNA within months after moving to Santa Monica. His name is Wellington Moreno, we connected because he is Dominican from the Bronx, you know me, I love my color people. Mr. Moreno greeted me with a warning: “I hope you are not coming here to cause any trouble”.  It can only go uphill from there, yes?  Wrong. Next stop was the sign in table to get my ticket for a free drink (the invitation said drinks, as in plural).  I shook hands with Ms. Christopoulos whom I contacted months before to discuss Compassionate Santa Monica.  She also serves in the Santa Monica Commission on the Status of Women. I thought it would be easy to sit and meet, after all, it is part of her job. Correct? Wrong again.  I was snubbed and unfriended from her Facebook page.  I’ll take my speech somewhere else, not everyone has a taste for compassion in this town.  Take note, Santa Monica is the first city in LA County to sign the Charter for Compassion, and the 4th city in the whole state of California.  Did I mentioned it was a unanimous vote by our City Council?  It was, back in September 2013.  I have been in the compassion movement for three years now.  Not an easy task.  I am a developer of sorts, I build compassionate cities, and it is the slowest growth of all developments.

Around 7:30 PM speeches started.  Ms. Christopoulos time came up and she scolded the audience because they were not listening to her, and ask people to be quiet. I do event planning through my company New MOON Media & Communications.  My piece of free advice: never give alcohol and food to your guests and wait more than 30 minutes before starting the speech portion of an event. When her please didn’t work, she deployed her bomb:

“I am half German, so you know, I have all the time in the world” ~ Elena Christopoulos, Political Consultant, Speaker, Communications Consultant, President of DNA & Commissioner of the Status of Women in Santa Monica

Should I be scared?  What does that mean? Oy vey!

My grandfather Maximillian Cohen was Jewish, I was raised Catholic. I’m surprised to find out that Elena has a website offering political advisor, communications, and speaker services.  Interesting choice of words and attitude, especially since she was stressing civility and diversity throughout the night.  Entitled?  You be the judge of that.

My issue here is that I’m commited to moving the needle of diversity in Santa Monica as much as I can.  I’m also commited to policing its authenticity and control any cultural appropiation to advance a political agenda.

“Cultural appropriation typically involves members of a dominant group exploiting the culture of less privileged groups — often with little understanding of the latter’s history, experience and traditions.” ~Nadra Kareem Little, Race Relations Expert

According to Wikipedia, block parties are reported as a World War I innovation originating from the East Side of New York City, where an entire block was roped off and patriotic songs sung and a parade held to honor the members of that block who had gone off to war. Traditionally, many inner city block parties were actually held illegally, because they did not file for an event permit from the local authorities. However, police turned a blind eye to them.  Block parties gained popularity in the United States during the 1970s, particularly within the hip hop community. Block parties were often held outdoors and power for the DJ’s sound system was taken illegally from street lights, as referenced in the song “South Bronx” by KRS-One.

This was not one of those block parties, evidenced by the end portion of the evening.  After Peter and Travis DCP presentation, only board members were allowed to ask questions because, after all, they are paying for the party, those were her literal words.  WOW!  I was raised to have my guests be the center of attention and cater to their wants and needs.  That’s how I roll!

“Tact is the art of making a point without making an enemy” ~Isaac Newton

ENTRE BROMA Y BROMA…LA VERDAD SE ASOMA (Google it!)

It gets better! Tim Harter, Senior Field Representative of Assemblyman Richard Bloom (Jewish) California State Legislator Office was a speaker at the event as well.  He later posted in Facebook about the event:

Community engagement is a vital function of a healthy community!! Learning about the Downtown Community Plan with the Downtown Neighborhood Association (DNA) and North of Wilshire (NOW). ” ~Tim Harter, Board Mamber of NOW 

“Soon, perhaps in the next few weeks, the California legislature will vote on Bloom’s controversial bill (AB2844) “California Combatting the Boycott, Divestiture, and Sanctions (BDS) of Israel Act of 2016.” This bill – also co-sponsored by State Senator Ben Allen (D-Santa Monica) – would bar state and local contracts with any private company boycotting Israel and its occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem. Private companies refusing to demolish homes or run segregated bus systems in illegally occupied territory could find themselves on a government blacklist, as Bloom’s bill – reminiscent of the McCarthy era – requires the state Attorney General to keep a list of Israel boycotters.” ~Marcy Winograd, Santa Monica Daily Press

I wonder how Bloom and Harter feel about the Nazi rhetoric of Ms. Elana Christopolos. Does Ms. Christopoulos is aware of the Jewish Community in Santa Monica?  A worthy political advisor has to be cognizant of those details.  Where she lacked in diversity understanding she has in financial resources, evidenced by her website.  I am going to hold on the blonde jokes, I don’t want the backlash this weekend. Seriously, can someone give this lady a better script?  If this is how she sells diversity, is time to call the crisis management team. Oy Vey!

 

It strucked me as odd that Ms. Christopoulos presented Santa Monica as the ideal space to live for her because she can:” jog in the morning, hike at noon and surf in the afternoon.”  She is one fit woman for sure!  Skinny Blonde, would be an appropiate title for a fitness blog (I charge for my ideas just in case). I can’t relate to her speech. I’m working to establish the board of Compassionate Santa Monica, plan and execute fundraisers, raise capital, manage a startup: diversitymatters.co and run New MOON Media & Communications.  In other words….I have to work.  I don’t have the luxury of spending my days working out for a skinny bod.  I schedule an hour of yoga or fitness class and 30 minutes of steam room in the evening at the Water Garden Bay Club to keep my mojo going.  There are countless of Santa Monica residents that do not have the luxury of wellness, despite the fact that Santa Monica was a finalist of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation for their culture of wellness, and won the Bloomberg Philantrophy Award for the Wellness Project.  Food for thought.

Rudeness

 

AUTHENTIC DIVERSITY: TACO CHALLENGE & BE VISIBLE

Raising LATINO voter registration is something I’m involved in through an initiative from Beatriz Acevedo mitu Network, a Santa Monica Media Company.

Mitu as the voice of Latino millennials is committed to inspiring Latino youth in civic engagement. While Latinos may be driving population growth, only one of three Latino millennials are using their voice to vote. We are represented in numbers, but we are not represented in votes.

Taco ch

As the largest digital media brand, they are able to harness video content and social activations to inspire young U.S. Latinos to take action and make their voices heard.

They have created a unique crossbreed of content that has engaged their audience a million times over. By intersecting the world of hard news and popular culture in a social-friendly format, their audience has not only watched their video content, but has become engaged in the national discourse. For example, Mixing a pop icon, like Selena, and creating a song that encourages people to vote, in the Selenagram Voting video, has garnered over 1 million views, over 14,000 shares and comments like this “Wow we have power in numbers!!!!! Latinos stand up, get involved, and vote for the only candidate that has our best interest.” Not only are people commenting on the video, but they are commenting on the comments. We’re watching Latino millennials become an active part shaping the future of our country.  The power of social video with their community is very powerful and mitú will always use it to engage and inspire our youth.

Beatriz is an inspiring role model and speaker,  we reconnected three weeks ago at the BE VISIBLE Event at Cal State LA, where I found my tribe.  When I was tasked with asking her a question after her presentation, I brought the issue of Santa Monica’s  at-large vs. district elections debate.  That’s how I became aware of the Take Action Commit Others Challenge. #TACOChallenge

Be Visible LatinaTo learn more about Be Visible go here: BE VISIBLE

“We will use mitú’s massive social reach through its video content to engage and inspire Latino millennials to have a say in how our country will be run and encourage them to get out and vote.
We are excited that so many celebrities and social influencers have joined our T.A.C.O. Challenge by agreeing to take action and commit others to vote,” ~Beatriz Acevedo, President and Co-founder of mitú.

Join us tomorrow at the #TACOChallenge.

The special events will feature live performances, food and voter registration booths. Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti is a supporter of this movement and will be onsite helping to get voters registered.  Other expected event guests include Rosario Dawson, Richard Cabral, Diego Boneta, Nick Gonzalez, Jackie Cruz, Efren Ramirez, Chef Marcela Valladolid, La Santa Cecilia, Maya Jupiter, Kat Dahlia, Eric Ochoa “SUPEReeeGO”, Luan Palomera, Yulema Ramirez.

Rosario Dawson is excited to join the movement and attend the event. “Latino millennials are the face of the new American majority. Together, we have a responsibility to transform our democracy and ensure that every person has a voice in the political process,” said Dawson. “That’s why I’m proud to be a part of a historic effort to register and activate 1 million Latino millennials. This election will be decided by us, all of us, and we must do everything in our power to ensure that we create the kind of future that we know is indeed possible,” she continued.

Organizations dedicated to helping mitú reach the voter registration goal include, City of Los Angeles, Revolve Impact, Toberman Neighborhood Center, Divine Forces Media, NCLR, FWD.us, Rock the Vote, CHIRLA, Voto Latino, Define American, Mi Familia Vota, LULAC, United We Dream, NHMC, NALIP, Homeboy Industries, Center for Community Change, LifeBoxset, Communities in Schools, Youth Justice Coalition, Homies Unidos , Gathering for Justice , Project Kinship , Anti-Recidivism Coalition, Sankofa, The Courage Campaign, Inner-City Struggle, New Earth, Street Poets, Alliance for Community Empowerment, Arts for LA and All of Us or None Los Angeles.

WRITING AS MEDICINE

The daily task, practice and dicipline of writing allows me to process ideas that would otherwise go unexamined.  I proudly belong to the Joan Didion school of thought:

“I write entirely to find out what I’m thinking, what I’m looking at, what I see and what it means. What I want and what I fear.”~Joan Didion

To have a forum to express my ideas freely is part of my wellness project, is healing.  Oh, yes I also have a company that provide wellness programs.  I am a certified Kundalini Yoga and Pilates Instructor.  You can find more information about us here: The Wellness Project.  We were in business way before the city of Santa Monica came up with their original idea.

I welcome vigorous debate and treat our City Manager Rick Cole with the same transparent honesty and respect I do with Portia, the Metro Rail Ambassador at the Bergamot Metro Station, or Domingo the server at the Ralph’s market Bistro who travels three hours by bus to get to work each day in the morning and evening.  Is who I am, because I was raised in diversity, where manners were meant for everyone, not only those who agreed with my politics.

I leave you with sincere Shabbat Shalom wishes from the bottom of my heart!

 

DIVERSITY DISFRANCHISEMENT

By: Zoë Muntaner

According to Wikipedia disfranchisement (also called disenfranchisement) is the revocation of the right of suffrage (the right to vote) of a person or group of people, or through practices, prevention of a person exercising the right to vote. Disfranchisement is also termed to the revocation of power or control of a particular individual, community or being to the natural amenity they abound in; that is to deprive of a franchise, of a legal right, of some privilege or inherent immunity. Disfranchisement may be accomplished explicitly by law or implicitly through requirements applied in a discriminatory fashion, intimidation, or by placing unreasonable requirements on voters for registration or voting.

36ee9ae9-e0c7-4053-86de-0fa95699699f

Fellow Santa Monica resident, activist, wife, daughter, friend & filmmaker Holly Mosher produced provocative documentaries that explore the subject with John Wellington Ennis directing.

“We decided to offer our film Free For All online for free after the voting fiascos sweeping the nation from Brooklyn to Arizona, hundreds of thousands, if not millions are being disenfranchised. Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act was gutted by the Supreme Court and since then laws that make voting harder have popped up in over 22 states across the country. The people and neighborhoods most affected by both voting ID laws and reductions of polling places are usually in the high concentration of minority neighborhoods. It is important to let everyone know what is going on and help empower them to protect their voting rights. It’s up to us to demand free and fair elections for all.” ~Holly Mosher & John Wellington Ennis

For more information and to watch films for free until May 9, 2016, go to the link:

SAVE OUR ELECTIONS

To read John Wellington Ennis Huffington Post piece click on the following link:

CONFRONTING VOTER SUPPRESSION IN 2016

I met Holly at the premiere of her last film Pay 2 Play in 2014, which deals with POLITICAL campaign finance issues.  We became fast friends.  Out of that film the platform of developers money in Santa Monica political campaigns was born.  Sorry guys, this one is on me!   That’s why I was so baffled with Phil Brock flip flop when he solicited and received the maximum donation from a local developer.  Whoever gives you money owns you, therefore, influences your vote on City Council.   Because he was exposed, he returned the money, but the damage was done.  Will you keep trusting candidates that go behind the curtain to practice the opposite of what they preach in their speeches?  Food for thought for the upcoming election.  Again, ACTIONS speak louder than words.

VOTE FOR LOVE

I vote with love in mind, it was the theme of my 2014 Campaign for Santa Monica City Council.  I didn’t get elected, but I won an incredible amount of experience and the integrity of walking my talk.  VISIT MY FACEBOOK PAGE IN THE LINK HERE:

I WILL ALWAYS CHOOSE LOVE

At the time, I didnt know anything about the Kousser Report, the At-Large Elections vs. District Elections debate, and why is so difficult to get elected in Santa Monica if you belong to the category I belong.  Now, I understand, Kimbery Ellis, Executive Director of Emerge California, an organization that is changing the face of California politics by identifying, training and encouraging women to run for office, get elected and to seek higher office answered my question during the Santa Monica Democratic Club Meeting last week:

“Generally speaking, research indicates that women and ethnic minorities fare better in district elections.” ~Kimberly Ellis, Executive Director Emerge CA

Their intensive, cohort-based four-month training program is unique. As the number of elected Democratic women remains flat or even declines, the need for their work is growing.

California became a state in 1850 but has yet to elect a female Governor. Despite being more than 50% of the population, currently, less than 30% of California state legislators are women.

A pool of highly qualified Democratic candidates is being left untapped. Too often, women do not see themselves running for office—they assume they aren’t experienced enough or they don’t know where to begin. Emerge California is changing that!

Emerge California is part of a national network currently working in 16 states: Arizona, California, Colorado, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Vermont, Virginia, and Wisconsin.

For more information about Emerge CA, go to the link: EMERGE CA

To read some research on the debate of distric vs.at-large elections go here: Electoral Institutions, Gender Stereotypes, and Women’s Local Representation

I am passionate about the subject, hence the tag line of this blog: Who was in the room?

SPEAKING ABOUT LOVE…

Ms. Mosher introduced me to a new coffee shop on Ocean Park Boulevard aptly named LOVE Coffee Bar.  Is where I am sitting as I type in my keyboard the words on this blog. I can’t drink coffee, I’m too hyper as it is, and don’t need the caffeine effect. Holly dared me to taste their coffee, and she was right.  It is beyond anything I’ve ever tasted before, is like drinking an exquisite Tiramisu.

The decor is clean, they have a back outdoor patio, a front bench to read a book or paper, meet a friend and watch people pass by, soft music, elegant yet comfy, small business owned by a Latino, classy…like me.  Like everything else in Sunset Park, it has that unmistakable neighborhood feel that Santa Monicans are losing fast if they don’t act with LOVE in the upcoming election.  Zina Josephs would not allow that in the hood. To learn more about Zina’s & Holly’s neighborhood go here:

SUNSET PARK NEIGHBORHOOD IN SANTA MONICA

LOVE Coffee Bar has a well curated Instagram page, I’m a sucker for good social media.  I own a boutique Public Relations, Marketing, Production and Digital Media company and their social media game has my seal of approval.  For more information about my work you can find us on Facebook:

New MOON Media & Communications

To see LOVE Cofee Bar images go to the link:

LOVE COFFEE BAR EXHIBITS (Instagram)

Speaking about elections, I read on Facebook that the Land Use Voter Empowerment (LUVE) Initiative got 10,000 signatures to be submitted tomorrow with a celebration in front of City Hall.

LUVE calls for a halt to the over-development of Santa Monica by giving voters the right to decide how much development is right for Santa Monica. LUVE would require voter approval for Major Development Review Permits and require voter approval for major changes in the City’s Land Use PolicyDocuments.  The LUVE Initiative was written by Armen Melkonians and Tricia Crane, board members of Residocracy.org, an online direct democracy advocacy tool for residents.

6,430 signatures – ten percent of registered Santa Monica Voters – are required to qualify LUVE for the Nov. 8 ballot. The Committee for the LUVE Initiative did its own validity verification and is confident that the 10,000 signatures they are submitting are more than the number needed to qualify the initiative for the ballot.

That was a labor of LOVE, I must congratulate everyone involved that worked hard for democracy.   The ironic thing is that the celebration coincides with the Mexican 5 de MAYO Celebration, despite Kate Bransfield, board member of Residiocracy claims on Facebook:

“Zoe, This has nothing to do with race, diversity, affordable housing or any other trumped up Trojan horse. This is about quality of life for all current Santa Monica residents. Those of all races and all socio-economic groups. If development were to go forward as planned, the quality of life for ALL residents would be greatly diminished.  Period.” ~Kate Bransfield

Who said race? I didn’t.

Kate is a supporter of Phil Brock and got a bad case of flip-flop syndrome which manifested symptoms in the above-referenced quote.  Unless the celebration is moved for another day it will be celebrated during Cinco de Mayo, which is not Mexican Independence Day–that is in September–but the celebration of one very important battle.  LUVE signature gathering was a battle, not the war. That will be fought in the following months.  It seems to me like it was about diversity after all…Ironic, no?

As they say: KARMA is a Blessing!

 

The WHITE elephant in the room

By: Zoë Muntaner

Before I start, I want to thank our City Manager, Rick Cole for giving me 40 minutes of his time today and listening to the projects I’d like to bring forth to our city.  We had a productive exchange of ideas and the seeds of change were planted.  Mayor Pro Tem Ted Winterer joined us at the end of the meeting, we reminisced on the words of former LA Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa eulogy of former LA Councilman Bill Rosendahl’s at his Saint Monica’s memorial last week: “Dime con quien andas, y te dire quien eres” (Google it!)

EXTRA, EXTRA, EXTRA!!!!!

A Coalition of Latino Residents and Neighborhood Groups Filed Lawsuit today against the City of Santa Monica. Challenging At-Large Election System in Santa Monica, Plaintiffs Claim At Large Elections Violate the California Voting Rights Act.

White Elephant

Santa Monica, California – Four months after minority residents notified the City of Santa Monica that its at-large system of electing its City Council violates the California Voting Rights Act (“CVRA”), and having received no response from the City, a coalition of Latino residents and neighborhood groups filed a lawsuit in Los Angeles Superior Court today, demanding an end to Santa Monica’s racially-discriminatory election system.  The lawsuit was brought by the Pico Neighborhood Association (PNA), Maria Loya – a Latina activist and resident of Santa Monica, and Advocates for Malibu Public Schools (AMPS).   Since at-large elections were adopted in Santa Monica 70 years ago, only one Latino has ever been elected to the City Council.  According to a report commissioned by the City in 1992, that is exactly why at-large elections were adopted in 1946 – to keep the minority residents living in the southern portion of the City from achieving representation.   “As a mother, former city council candidate and resident of the Pico Neighborhood, I want to ensure that future elections are fair.  The current at-large election system is illegal and has led to a lack of representation in local government, which in turn has led to neglect of our community.  All residents and every neighborhood can benefit from a neighborhood-centered approach to representative democracy.” stated Maria Loya.  Ms. Loya ran for City Council in 2004, and although she was overwhelmingly preferred by Latino voters, she placed 7th in a crowded field of 16 candidates for three seats.   “Aside from providing residents more fairness in their elections, district elections can decrease the influence of special interests and increase the influence of residents over what happens in their neighborhoods,” added Cris McCleod, Chair of the Pico Neighborhood Association.   Historically marginalized communities have used the CVRA to gain representation in municipal governments across the State.  “In the 14 years since the CVRA was enacted, it has brought fair elections to more than 200 cities, counties and school districts.  In the case of Santa Monica not only do the at-large elections violate the CVRA, they violate the California Constitution as well because they were adopted with the purpose of disenfranchising racial minorities,” explained attorney Kevin Shenkman who represents the Plaintiffs.  Mr. Shenkman and his co-counsel – Rex Parris, Milton Grimes and Robert Rubin – has won hotly-contested CVRA cases against the cities of Highland and Palmdale, which was ultimately ordered by the court to adopt district-based elections after spending an estimated $7 million in legal fees.  Other cities, like Hemet, Buena Park and Wildomar have voluntarily changed their election systems in response to letters from that legal team.   “In our efforts to improve Malibu public schools, we have become keenly aware of how at-large elections prevent minority groups from having their voices heard.  The intentionally discriminatory provision of the Santa Monica City Charter prevents not only the City, but also the Santa Monica-Malibu School District, from adopting district-based elections; we want the school board to be empowered to voluntarily adopt fair elections, and set an example for the students,” said Roui Israel, President of Advocates for Malibu Public Schools.  Although seen as a wealthy liberal bastion, Santa Monica is a tale of two cities where minority residents living in the Pico Neighborhood have endured gang violence and all the other problems associated with California’s less-wealthy regions.  Many residents have claimed for years that the City neglects their needs. “Our City leaders have an opportunity to bring justice to one of our City’s darkest moments, when people of color were deliberately disenfranchised.  I hope that one day every resident and every neighborhood is represented in our government. Residents deserve equal representation, a stronger democracy and an electoral system that increases the influence of residents and decreases the influence of big donors,“ stated School Board Member and Pico Neighborhood resident Oscar de la Torre.  Click on the link below to learn more:

Santa Monica Fair Elections Website

THE KOUSSER REPORT

I became aware of the Kousser Report yesterday through one of my sources who directed me to the smfairelections.com website.  Today I gave a copy of the report to our City Manager Rick Cole in a scheduled meeting to discuss the 2016 agenda of Compassionate Santa Monica & DIVERSITY MATTERS.  Mr. Cole has never seen the report before and agreed to read it and get back to me with a comment.  Basically the report findings established that if the City of Santa Monica wants to avoid the costly litigation of a lawsuit and public embarrassment of a racially discriminatory intent to prevent fair racial representation in our city government, they should replace the at-large system with elections by district. A waste of financial resources on its way…

This begs the question: What is worst? The people who initially committed the crime or the ones that knew it happened and did nothing about it, benefiting cycle after cycle to remain in power?  Silence is compliance.

I personally have been victimized by the vicious monster of racial bias by city employees of Santa Monica. (That is subject to a whole new post intended for the future).  This is the WHITE elephant in the room (no pun intended); both city officials and residents fail to address the issue and stuff it under a rug.   The problem with that, is that it’s not a sustainable strategy.  Sooner or later someone chooses to do a “Spring Cleaning”(no pun intended, I am behind mine) and the dirt come out to air polluting a carefully crafted narrative that no longer holds. Ohhhhh, Spring what have you brought us this year!

Who was in the room?  was the question that started this blog, now we know that the white elephant (no pun intended) has been in the room all this time.  How authentically diverse is the City of Santa Monica? Can a Liberal be a Racist? Are you familiar with the Inkwell statue?  Can we have a real diverse represented democratic government with at-large election system?  Do you know that the first City Council of color was appointed not elected, and when he ran in an election he lost? This is a National conversation I intend to start here.

NORMAL PEOPLE LIKE US

On March 25, I attended the Social Services Commission meeting at The Ken Edward Center to learn about how the City of Santa Monica is addressing homelessness.  I went  with an open mind to hear different perspectives, but as I listened to reports from the Santa Monica Police and OPCC (Ocean Park Community Center) who manages most of the homeless shelters in the city, I became aware that the reason we have not made progress with the issue is the lack of compassion and tag line of this blog: Who was in the room?  I will be posting an interview with Shawn Landers in an upcoming post to discuss issues related to the Social Services Commission.  Click in the link below for more information:

Social Services Commission-Community & Cultural Services

At one point, one of the Commissioners phrased a question referring to “most of us” then went on to speak saying: “you know what I mean, normal people like US”.  I checked out, my skin started to itch, I could not stay one more second in the room… but I patiently waited until I addressed with candor the lack of compassion and empathy from the comment.  See, the only person who has spent time in a homeless shelter in that meeting was me.  I have four years of field experience with the homeless population.  Is part of my daily interactions on the bus and streets of Santa Monica.   I can tell you they are PEOPLE like us, with unfortunate circumstances and no access to mental healthcare.  If we claim to be a model of a Wellbeing Community and affirm the Charter for Compassion, we must address the issues of inequality head on without fear or shame.  The conversation is over, is time for action. Compassionate ACTION.

As the old adage goes: “Actions speak louder than words”

 

DIVERSITY OF OPINIONS

By: Zoë Muntaner

Robert Frank Charleston
@ROBERT FRANK, Charleston,  South Carolina 1955 from “The Americans”

 

Through the years, people asked me to blog about any of my many passions. It took me a while to finally commit and launch something sustainable with meaning and purpose.  Thanks to everyone that read the inaugural post and to the many who encouraged me to write it.  I’m profoundly grateful and humbled by the praise and road ahead.  With purpose, I will give voice to the less fortunate and push the boundaries of our thinking with compassion.  My aim is to bring  light and awareness to issues vital to our community and the world at large.  Your feedback is always welcome and brings hope that one single person can make a difference.  In the words of Activist & Nobel Laureate, Malala Yousafzai: “When the whole world becomes silent, even one voice becomes powerful”

Malala

 

That was the meme I used to tweet about the Santa Monica Democratic Club presentation & discussion of the Downtown Community Plan (formerly Downtown Specific Plan)  this past Wednesday at the Santa Monica Main Library.  The panel included Santa Monica planning director David Martin, community activist and Ocean Park Organization board member Mary Marlow who co-chairs a neighborhood group subcommittee studying the DCP, and architect Ron Goldman, a member of Santa Monica Architects for a responsible tomorrow (SMart) which is also studying the DCP.   Although they brought flash drives with their respective presentations, no one brought a laptop and mine was designated to make the visuals available to all. Hence, now everyone not present that night can view the presentations by clicking on the names here:

David Martin

Mary Marlow

SMArat

You be the judge of what you envision Downtown Santa Monica should look like for future generations. I respect my readers too much to encourage support or boycott petitions.  I also respect the democratic process that allows citizens to take control of their desitny and encourage active participation in the political process.  Anyone who discourages the activism of its citizens in the process is not a friend of democracy. My job is to present information and data, your job is to analyze it.  DIVERSITY MATTERS is about sharing different perspectives of our own humanity and how we approach the daily task of living while affirming our personal and political identities.  I am inspired by grassroots organization, the mobilization that evolves our democracy.  Bernie Sanders Campaign is an example of how committed citizens can transform the political culture and create revolutionary results.  In our city, Residiocracy proved to inspire residents through the Hines referendum and now they are trying to repeat the feat with the Land Use Voter Empowerment (LUVE).  I dig living in a city of engaged political discourse.  As a Sander’s newsletter in my inbox read: “Our power comes from a simple, timeless truth: when people come together, there is nothing we cannot accomplish.”

ROBERT FRANK @ BERGAMOT STATION

Bergamot Station Arts Center continues to be a hub of artistic activity unrivaled not only in the city of Santa Monica but in the Western United States.  Robert Frank, one of the most important visual artists, (His photos bookend this post.) has created an exhibition of works presently on view at building g-1 home of the old Santa Monica Museum of Art.  This show is compiled of the artist’s photographic prints, books, and films. It is a most amazing feat to have an exhibition of this importance and magnitude at Bergamot Station, and for this we must thank Shoshana and Wayne Blank, the founders of Bergamot Station Arts Center; Richard Ehrlich of UCLA; Steidl Publishing House; and the Steve Tisch foundation, all of whom had the vision and fortitude to bring to our city a world class show that will be traveling to 40 other international museums and institutions. The exhibit is the brainchild of Gerhard Steidl, Robert Frank’s longtime friend and publisher. In New York Gerhard Steidl gave a Master Class to students and post doctoral candidates -“How To Make A Book” and offered critiques to any interested students.  The exhibition was was a smashing hit!  Thus our mandate is clear: to duplicate if not surpass it in LA at the Santa Monica Museum space at Bergamot Station.  Robert Frank: Books & Films 1947-2016 runs through April 16, 2016.  Do not miss it!

New York Times Review

VOGUE Magazine Review

At a time when the city of Santa Monica, owner of most of the land the arts center inhabits, is contemplating a plan to turn the center into an office building and hotel complex, it is very important to note that the artist, his collaborators, and supporters chose Bergamot Station because of its worldwide reputation for being an accessible and open arts venue for all to come and appreciate and enjoy for free. Robert Frank’s most iconic body of work, ‘The Americans’, photographs made on several road trips throughout the United States in the 1950s, is best known for its portrayal of the inequality of race and economics that existed in this period of American history. Right now, in 2016, we, Americans, are confronted by such very similar issues.

The City of Santa Monica has long had the reputation of being a haven for those committed to racial, economic and cultural diversity. I fear this is no longer true. The city seems bent on becoming an enclave of the wealthy and privileged. Do we really need another hotel / office business park?  When all is said and done, a forward thinking city needs to realize that investing in the cultural life of its citizens is also the best investment for the economic life of the city. At this moment, we are at a critical juncture. The galleries at Bergamot Station have a vested interest in continuing to bring to the our audience significant, far-reaching and diverse exhibitions and events that enrich and enhance our collective lives in our city. The Robert Frank exhibition is a most fine example of what they strive to accomplish day in and out. Robert Frank has stated that his intention with this exhibition is to make young folks aware of these works. When asked what advice he would give a young photographer, he responded -“keep your eyes open”!!!  That advice also applies to Santa Monica residents that concern themselves with the dramatic changes to the character of our city and the direction the Planning & Community Development Department is taking.  The second day of the exhibition I witnessed hundreds of students from all parts of Los Angeles County at the center. This is community at its best. Diversity lives at Bergamot Station.

MARIMBA MADE ME DO IT

Last Sunday I went the Main Street Farmer’s Market to get groceries.  The sun was hiding behind clouds but the atmosphere was celebratory and joyful.  At this point, I’d like to introduce another member of the Santa Monica community, Venice HS teacher and community organizer Marcy Winograd. Marcy and I met up at the busy Main Street Farmers Market last Sunday.

IMG_1265

Marcy shared with me: “Standing there at the Farmer’s Market, a few blocks from my home, I felt as though I was at the intersection of African, Latin, and American traditions” as the talented Masanga Marimba band captivated the crowd with beats and song from Zimbabwe and Latin America .”

(Remember that I’m Latina, I hear Latin sounds and I am trasported, anything can happen when I hear Afrocaribbean sounds, so I allowed Marcy to tape me and share in Facebook to much of my embarasment.)

Back to Marcy … “According to the band’s website (masanga.com), “The word Masanga comes from an African word that means coming together of rivers …” and indeed the lyrics and music brought people together of diverse ethnicities and ages. This wasn’t just a venue for adults but children, too, for in between jam sessions, when the band took a break, girls and boys, toddlers among them, practiced percussion, experimenting with their own brand of Marimba as their wrists went wild. Kudos to Dr. Ric Alviso, a CAL State Northridge ethnomusicologist and professor of World Music, for assembling this rare 9-member ensemble and bringing the beats to Santa Monica, and a special thanks to City staff for inviting Masanga for a repeat performance.”

Until next time, join the Diversity Bandwagon!

 

18_robert-frank_trolley-new-orleans_1955-512x333-512x264
@Robert Frank Trolley-New Orleans 1955 from “The Americans”